Choose Between Two Book Ideas

6 Views
0 Uses

Prompt

ChatGPT
Claude
Grok
OpenRouter
You are a candid publishing consultant and craft coach. I have two book ideas and can only write one next. Help me decide; the decision is mine.

Idea A: {{IDEA_A}}
Idea B: {{IDEA_B}}
My goals for the next book (e.g. finish a first novel, build a series, query agents, self-publish quickly): {{MY_GOALS}}
My strengths and weaknesses as a writer, honestly: {{MY_STRENGTHS}}

Compare the two ideas in a table with these rows: core conflict strength; how clearly the genre promise reads; series or standalone potential; research load; how well it plays to my strengths; how hard the ending will be; how much I seem excited by it (judge from my own wording).

Score each row 1-5 and give a one-line reason. Do not total the scores; some rows matter more than others for my goals.

Then:
- Tell me which idea you'd lean towards for my stated goals, and the single biggest risk of that choice.
- Ask me two questions whose answers would change your recommendation.
- Suggest a 1-week test I can run (e.g. write the opening scene of each, or a one-page synopsis) to decide with evidence instead of a feeling.

Don't invent market data or sales figures. If you refer to market trends, say they are general impressions to verify.

Customize this prompt

Fill in the variables below to personalize this prompt:

ChatGPT
Claude
Grok
OpenRouter

Model Settings

Recommended Models

ChatGPT Claude Gemini

Temperature

0.7

Max Tokens

2000

Additional Notes

Best for: Deciding which book to write next on craft and goals, not just mood

About this prompt

“Choose Between Two Book Ideas” is a free prompt for ChatGPT in the Writing & Creative category, 213 words long, added to The Prompt Index on October 28, 2026 by The Prompt Index. Copy it with the button above, paste it into ChatGPT or any other AI chat assistant, and send it.

It has 4 placeholders to fill in first: {{IDEA_A}}, {{IDEA_B}}, {{MY_GOALS}}, {{MY_STRENGTHS}}. Use the “Customize this prompt” fields to personalise it before you copy.

Recommended models: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini.

0 upvotes, sent to an AI tool 0 times, viewed 6 times.

Browse all Writing & Creative prompts, the AI prompt database or use the AI prompt finder to search every prompt.